|
|
||
"Encylopedia of Civil War Shiprecks" a good idea but could use some fact-checking. By Scott Boyd. Date published: 6/6/2009
THERE are some very "The Encyclopedia of Civil War Shipwrecks" by W. Craig Gaines aims to be a one-stop reference source for information on the famous and obscure ships lost in America's bloodiest war. By my count there are 1,837 named ships listed, along with 184 entries for unnamed ships (some of the latter are for more than one vessel, such as several unnamed small boats lost at the same time in the same location). In the preface, after discussing why he wrote the book, the author wisely defines exactly what constitutes a shipwreck for his purposes: "a vessel sunk, scuttled, burned, grounded, lost, capsized, missing, blown up, one that collided with another vessel or object and sank, or one that was generally made unusable without salvage and substantial repairs." It does include ships that were sunk and later raised and removed, such as the CSS H.L. Hunley--it's not just for wrecks still underwater. Next he describes how One way the author got around this was to include as locations named rivers (the Mississippi, Missouri and Ohio) in addition to the nearby states. The location also includes ships lost outside of modern U.S. territorial waters, such as New England whalers sunk in the Bering Sea near the Arctic The author forthrightly acknowledges how data found in various sources can be conflicting and contradictory. This is something every Civil War naval history researcher will encounter and must use his best judgment to resolve.
Date published: 6/6/2009
1. Be respectful. No personal attacks.
|
|
|||||||||||||||||