Fredericksburg.com - OPPONENTS SPEAK

search local
Follow us on Twitter Find us on Facebook

Get a printer-friendly version of this page. E-mail this story to a friend.
Make a post about this story on FredTalk.

OPPONENTS SPEAK
Preservation groups vow to continue fight against Wilderness Walmart despite Orange supervisors' decision
Date published: 8/26/2009

By CLINT SCHEMMER

Preservationists are dismayed by Orange County's approval of the Wilderness Walmart retail center, but aren't conceding defeat.

A national coalition of heritage groups will continue appealing to the retail giant to find an Orange site for its Supercenter that's farther from the Wilderness battlefield. The store site is a quarter-mile from Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania National Military Park.

"The ball is now in Walmart's court," James Lighthizer, president of the Civil War Preservation Trust, said yesterday. "Walmart better understands the nationwide anger generated by its proposal to build on the doorstep of a national park.

"It is in the corporation's best interests to work with the preservation community to find an alternative site. We are optimistic that company officials will see the wisdom of moving elsewhere."

But Wal-Mart spokesman Keith Morris ruled that out.

"It's clear that the public has spoken and there is considerable support for the store at the site," he said. "We would like to continue our open dialogue with these groups, but they appear to have other motives."

Calling the Walmart plan "misguided," Lighthizer said the trust and the other members of the Wilderness Battlefield Coalition will weigh all options for continuing their campaign.

"This battle is not over yet," he said.

The coalition was joined in its opposition to the Walmart by 253 of the nation's top historians, U.S. Sen. Jim Webb, D-Va., Virginia Gov. Tim Kaine, House Speaker Bill Howell, R-Stafford, Congressmen Ted Poe, R-Texas, and Peter Welch, D-Vt., the Vermont Legislature, Pulitzer prize-winning authors David McCullough and James McPherson, and TV documentarian Ken Burns.

Asked yesterday whether legal action is now likely, coalition leaders declined to speculate.

But the coalition will be "keeping up the drumbeat of opposition" to the project, said Jim Campi, the Civil War Preservation Trust's director of public policy. He noted that in battlefield controversies elsewhere, preservationists have proven to be tenacious.

"At Brandy Station in Culpeper County, we lost every zoning vote against an industrial park and a Formula One racetrack," Campi said. "But ultimately, we prevailed, and that battlefield is preserved. We're in this for the long haul."

Clint Schemmer: 540/368-5029
Email: cschemmer@freelancestar.com


"The Board of Supervisors' 4-1 vote was really no surprise. But we are not giving up on this."

--Orange County resident Jack Snyder, vice chairman, Piedmont Environmental Council's board

"It is now up to Wal-Mart to do the right thing and, of course, the right thing is to move the store a mile or so down the road. Then, everyone wins and Wal-Mart becomes the really, really good guy. We will keep the faith until the first shovel goes into the dirt."

--Zann Miner, president, Friends of the Wilderness Battlefield

"If this proposed superstore is built on Wilderness battlefield, just a stone's throw from the national park, it will set a terrible precedent and put all of our national parks at great risk of neglect and thoughtless development."

--Richard Moe, president, National Trust for Historic Preservation

"It is not necessary to desecrate the land where a horrific battle took place less than 150 years ago in pursuit of profit and pavement. Despite last night's disappointing vote, we will continue to explore options to protect this important national park. We continue to hold out hope that Wal-Mart will do the right thing by relocating its business, and respect and protect America's heritage and history."

--Catharine Gilliam, Virginia program manager, National Parks Conservation Association



Date published: 8/26/2009



Most recent reader comments:

Viewing 5 out of 28 comments. (Sorted in reverse order, with most recent post at the top.)

Display comments on this page. | Sort:

PLEASE READ: These reader comments are not moderated. Each user is solely responsible for any message (s)he posts here. The Free Lance-Star does not endorse the views expressed within these comments. All users who post to this Web site must agree to the terms of the FredTalk User Agreement. We rely on our readers to police themselves, and report any content that violates our User Agreement. In accordance with our User Agreement, we reserve the right to remove any post at any time for any reason, and will restrict access of registered users who repeatedly violate our terms. Any reader can report inappropriate content by clicking the "Report this post to admins" link at the bottom of each comment. You need not be registered to report a post.

Liberals and their ridiculous opinions of Wal Mart (posted by mustang2 , Aug. 27, 2009 3:06 pm)    0 likes
I know it's hard to believe but many of Wal Mart's customers are poor and need to shop there in order to provide adequately for their families. The Chinese made products are inexpensive and that's a good thing for these people. Wal Mart makes a great target because they are big. If Wal Mart does not locate at the intersection, another store or stores will. Capitalism allows stores to sell what they want and people to buy what they want. This is freedom and it's what makes our country great.

Grumpy and Misinformed? (posted by VAREB , Aug. 27, 2009 9:04 am)    0 likes
Grumpy, first the US does not own Omaha Beach. We have a cemetery there beyond the beach with 9,000 Americans who gave their lives. Who owns it is not the issue, how it is protected is. Do a google earth and zoom in on Omaha Beach and take a look up and down the beach and tell me how many commercial buildings you see within miles of where those men died. WalMart can afford to go elsewhere. A quarter mile down the road near Bloom will not hurt their sales nor impact on the Wilderness. It is the right thing.

CUstomer Service Lousy in VA (posted by 4merstaf4dian , Aug. 27, 2009 7:04 am)    0 likes
As a retired Marine, I have enjoyed shopping at WalMarts all over the country. I can say without doubt that the customer service was always great, except in Fredericksburg. I will acknowledge, however, that WalMart here in Fredtucky is still ahead of K-Mart's

WalMart customer service (posted by larryg , Aug. 26, 2009 11:09 pm)    0 likes
You know... Dollar General has TWICE as many stores as WalMart ... have you tried the customer service in those stores? This is more Luddite stuff. Mom & Pop stores might have had more knowledgeable customer service but they did not pay any better and most of then do not provide any health insurance at all. this is just plain silly. All modern retailers pretty much function like WalMart does. Go look for customer service in a Costco or K-mart or Target.... people are using a double-standard

Well... (posted by GaryShorts , Aug. 26, 2009 9:41 pm)    0 likes
when I'm working at Walmart and all you Walmart haters are looking for everyday low prices, don't ask me for help finding anything because I either not know or don't care to help you....but seriously, I think one of the reasons Walmart is so hated is because of the poor customer service customers get. Which is a result from poor quality hiring and training. But building on historic ground is just a direct insult to traditionalists and preservationists..

What do you think?
Enter your FredTalk username and password to post a comment on this story. If you are registered on FredTalk or another part of this site, use that login here. Otherwise, you can just REGISTER here... .

Posting guidelines

1. Be respectful. No personal attacks.
2. Please avoid offensive, vulgar, abusive, hateful or defamatory language.
3. Agree to read & follow THE RULES.
4. Use the "report to admins" link for posts which violate the rules. 5. Keep it on-topic. Posts which contribute nothing of value to the conversation will be deleted.

Username:
Password:

Post title:


Please keep it brief (Limit is 512 characters). Please note, attempts to circumvent this limit by making
multiple posts back-to-back (ex: 'continued', 'part1, 2', etc) will be deleted.

Please make sure CAPS LOCK is off. Posts in ALL CAPS will be deleted.)


By checking this box, you agree to the terms of the FredTalk User agreement.









The Free Lance-Star fredericksburg.com 93.3 WFLS Print Innovators Classic Rock 96.9 99.3 The Vibe wntx radio